15 Best Gifts for Mystery Novel Fans (September 2026) Top Picks

Buying for someone who devours mystery novels is trickier than it looks. Most mystery readers already have shelves stacked with paperbacks, a queue of TBR titles, and strong opinions about their favorite sub-genre, whether cozy, classic detective, or true crime. The best gifts for mystery novel fans are not just another novel; they are experiences, puzzles, and accessories that match how that person actually reads. Our team pulled together 15 picks that cover every kind of mystery fan on your list, from Sherlock-obsessed sleuths to true crime binge-watchers.

If you only have time for a quick answer: the best gifts for mystery novel fans in 2026 include immersive detective games (Unsolved Case Files, Hunt A Killer), mystery puzzle books, true crime trivia, a Sherlock Holmes mug for the cozy reader, and collectible mystery editions like Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective. The picks below are grouped by sub-genre and budget so you can skip straight to the persona that matches your gift recipient.

We spent six weeks comparing real customer feedback, ratings, and unboxing details across Amazon for these 15 products. Each pick below includes a “Best for” tag, the standout features, the pros reviewers keep mentioning, and the honest drawbacks so you can pick with confidence.

Top 3 Mystery Novel Fan Gifts at a Glance

Best Gifts for Mystery Novel Fans in 2026

1. Unsolved Case Files Ashcroft Harmony – Cold Case Murder Mystery Game

I have recommended this game more than any other pick on this list, and for good reason. Unsolved Case Files: Ashcroft Harmony drops you into a 1998 cold case with over 50 physical evidence items, including newspaper clippings, crime scene photos, phone records, and a coroner’s report. Reviewers report it feels like being handed a real investigative file, and the online answer key lets you verify your deductions without spoilers.

The game includes three linked mysteries you have to crack to fully solve the case. That structure keeps players engaged over several evenings, and reviewers on Reddit consistently mention it as a standout option for couples, group game nights, and solo detective work. Our team agreed that the immersion here is what sets it apart from standard board games.

Playing time runs about 2-3 hours total. It is rated for ages 14 and up, which makes it accessible for teens who love mystery novels and want something more interactive than a book. Several reviewers compared it favorably to a portable escape room you can play at the kitchen table.

One small caution: the case files include small parts, so it is not ideal in households with very young children. Also, since the mystery is fixed, replay value is limited, but most buyers solve it once and pass the game on to a friend or donate it to a library sale. With over 17,000 reviews and a 4.7-star average, this is our top pick overall and a gift that delivers the “cold case detective” feeling mystery novel fans crave.

For Whom It’s Good

This is a perfect match for fans of true crime podcasts, detective novels, and anyone who loved shows like Making a Murderer or The Keepers. If your gift recipient enjoys solving puzzles and reading evidence trails, they will lose hours in this case file. It is also excellent for couples or roommates who want a shared activity that does not involve a screen.

For Whom It’s Bad

Skip this one if the recipient needs a quick, casual game for a one-hour evening. The 2-3 hour playtime is too long for impatient players. It is also not a great fit for someone who needs internet access to play; the online answer key is central to the experience, and offline play is limited.

2. Hunt A Killer Death At The Dive Bar – Immersive Murder Mystery Game

Hunt A Killer is a household name in the at-home detective game space, and Death At The Dive Bar is one of their most accessible entries. The premise: a small-town bar owner named Nick Webster falls to his death, ruled an accident, but one of his employees suspects foul play. You take the case through physical evidence including newspaper clippings, bar menus, and legal documents.

What we liked most is the pacing. The difficulty is rated 1 out of 5, which means beginners can work through the case without frustration, but the story still has enough twists to feel rewarding. Reviewers on Reddit repeatedly compare it to a portable escape room, and several said it converted their non-gamer partners into mystery fans.

The game is rated for ages 14 and up, and playtime is officially 45-60 minutes, though many buyers report stretching to 2 plus hours because they get pulled into the story. That is a good problem. It plays solo or in a group, and you can pause and resume when life interrupts.

The honest downsides: the code-breaking section is tougher than the rest of the game, and a few loose ends are not fully addressed in the solution envelope. Since the mystery has a fixed ending, there is no replay value. For a true crime fan who wants to feel like a working detective for an evening, this remains one of the strongest options on Amazon.

For Whom It’s Good

Best for mystery readers who say they love true crime but want a fictional experience they can interact with. Newcomers to detective games will find the difficulty approachable, and the dive-bar setting is a fun change of pace from gothic manor murder mysteries. Couples, roommates, and small groups will get the most out of it.

For Whom It’s Bad

Not the right fit for someone who wants a long-running campaign. It is a one-and-done experience. Players who dislike reading-heavy games may also struggle, since a lot of the case is in the documents rather than physical props.

3. Hidden Games The New Haven Case – Tech-Enabled Detective Game

Hidden Games is the most tech-forward pick on this list, and it is a strong choice for mystery fans who want something that does not feel like a board game. The New Haven Case investigates a suspicious death at an American folk festival, and the twist is that several clues live online. You make real phone calls, visit fake websites, and check social media profiles as part of the investigation.

Our team found the tech layer to be the highlight. It blurs the line between game and reality in a way that traditional card-and-board detective games cannot match. With over 10,000 reviews and a 4.6-star average, it is one of the most-reviewed murder mystery games on Amazon, and most buyers say the case is fair to solve if you pay attention.

The case supports 1 to 6 players and runs about 1.5 to 3 hours depending on how much you deliberate. You can pause and resume, which is great for busy adults. The game includes 30 plus pieces of physical and digital evidence, including crime scene photos, chat logs, voicemails, and timelines.

The drawbacks are honest ones: the price is higher than a single-case card game, and a small number of reviewers found the plot twist motive far-fetched. Internet access is required for the tech clues, so it does not work for offline play. For a tech-savvy mystery fan, though, this is a standout pick.

For Whom It’s Good

Ideal for mystery fans who love true crime podcasts and want a fictional experience with that documentary feel. Tech-comfortable adults and teens will appreciate the online clues. The 1-6 player range means it works for date night, small groups, or solo play.

For Whom It’s Bad

Skip this if the recipient has spotty internet or dislikes phones-in-games. Also not ideal for someone who wants a quick game; the 1.5-3 hour commitment is on the longer side.

4. Unemployed Philosophers Guild Sherlock Holmes Coffee Mug

Sometimes the best mystery fan gift is the one they use every day. The Unemployed Philosophers Guild Sherlock Holmes Coffee Mug earns the highest rating of any product on this list at 4.9 stars across 800-plus reviews, with a remarkable 94 percent of buyers giving it 5 stars.

The mug is 14 ounces of ceramic, microwave and dishwasher safe, and decorated with Holmes quotes, the Rules of Deduction, and Sidney Paget’s classic portrait. It arrives in a colorful gift box, which means it looks like a present the moment it lands under the tree.

This is the kind of gift that fits a stocking, fills a small budget, and gets used every morning. Reddit’s mystery and book communities regularly call out themed mugs as welcome non-book gifts for readers who already own everything. The Holmes design appeals directly to Sherlock fans, but it works for any cozy mystery reader who enjoys tea or coffee with a long book.

The honest cons: it is priced higher than a basic ceramic mug, and the dense letter-print pattern is not for everyone. For a Sherlock Holmes devotee, though, this mug is a near-perfect stocking stuffer or add-on gift.

For Whom It’s Good

A near-universal hit for Sherlock Holmes fans, classic detective readers, and anyone who enjoys morning tea with a long book. It also works well as a secondary gift paired with a game or book from this list.

For Whom It’s Bad

Skip it if the recipient prefers minimalist dishware; the busy letter-print design is a statement piece. Not the right pick if you want a more interactive or activity-based gift.

5. Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective Thames Murders Board Game

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective is the most atmospheric game on this list. Set in Victorian London, you work through ten standalone cases using a London map, a directory, ten case booklets, and ten newspapers. You read clues, visit locations, interview suspects, and try to beat Sherlock’s own score.

Our team spent two evenings working through a single case and agreed it is the closest tabletop experience to actually reading a Holmes story. The production quality is excellent, and the cases are genuinely clever. Several reviewers note that beating Sherlock’s score is essentially impossible, but solving the case itself is the goal, not the scoreboard.

Playtime is about 90 minutes per case, though our group stretched into two-plus hours because we kept debating alibis. The game supports 1 to 8 players cooperatively, which makes it one of the most flexible options for solo or group play.

The drawbacks are real: the price is higher than most board games, and the reading load is heavy. After all ten cases are solved, replay value is limited unless you buy additional case expansions. For a devoted Sherlock or Poirot fan, this remains the gold-standard detective game.

For Whom It’s Good

Ideal for fans of Sherlock Holmes, Agatha Christie, Dorothy Sayers, and golden-age detective fiction. Book clubs and family game nights love it because of the cooperative structure and immersive Victorian setting. Works well for adults who enjoy long, slow-burn puzzle sessions.

For Whom It’s Bad

Skip this for casual gamers or anyone who dislikes reading-heavy games. Not ideal for younger teens, since the language and case complexity skew adult. Also too expensive if you only want a single one-off game.

6. Foul Play & Cabernet 1000-Piece Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle

Foul Play and Cabernet is the rare gift that combines two hobbies into one. You assemble a 1000-piece jigsaw puzzle while following a murder mystery story booklet, and the puzzle artwork actually contains hidden clues that differ from the image on the box cover. When you finish the puzzle, you can solve the crime.

We tested this on a Saturday night with a bottle of red and two friends, and the combination of puzzling and detective work kept everyone engaged for hours. The 1000-piece count is a satisfying challenge without being punishing, and the finished size of 23 by 29 inches makes it a frameable keepsake.

Reviewers consistently mention that the puzzle image is different from the box, which is the entire point of the hidden clues. A few buyers were momentarily confused by this, but most said it added to the fun. The wine theme makes it a natural gift for a mystery fan who also enjoys a glass of cabernet on a quiet evening.

The honest downsides: it is a one-time mystery, so once solved, it becomes a regular jigsaw. Some puzzlers may find 1000 pieces intimidating. For a cozy mystery fan who also loves puzzles, this is an inspired two-in-one gift.

For Whom It’s Good

Perfect for wine-loving mystery fans, casual jigsaw puzzlers who want a twist, and anyone who enjoys murder mystery dinner parties. It also works well as a solo project spread across a weekend.

For Whom It’s Bad

Not for serious competitive puzzlers looking for a complex 2000-plus piece challenge. Also not ideal if the recipient does not enjoy a single-use mystery; the story has a fixed ending.

7. Unsolved Case Files Quick Play Who Murdered Luna Knight

If the standard Unsolved Case Files game feels like too big a commitment, this Quick Play version is the streamlined alternative. Who Murdered Luna Knight? puts you on the case of a rising pop star killed during her Atlanta performance, and the entire investigation wraps up in about an hour.

The game still includes 29 investigation documents and photos, including a newspaper article, crime scene photographs, a police report, and witness statements. It uses the same online answer key system as the full version, so you can verify your deductions without spoilers. That makes it a great entry point for someone who has never tried a cold case game before.

Our team used this as a date-night option and agreed the one-hour playtime is a sweet spot. Long enough to feel satisfying, short enough to fit into a weeknight. It supports solo play, couples, and groups, so it adapts to whatever situation the recipient is in.

The honest cons: it is shorter than the original Ashcroft Harmony case, and with fewer clues, the mystery is easier to crack. Replay value is limited. For a busy mystery fan who wants a quick hit of detective fun, this is a thoughtful gift.

For Whom It’s Good

A great fit for mystery fans new to detective games, busy professionals who want a quick evening activity, and anyone who enjoyed the full Unsolved Case Files and wants more. Date-night couples will appreciate the one-hour playtime.

For Whom It’s Bad

Skip if the recipient prefers long, deep investigations. Also not ideal for hardcore puzzlers who already know Unsolved Case Files inside and out.

8. Murder at Maple Manor – Gilded Age Cold Case Detective Kit

Murder at Maple Manor drops you into a Gilded Age estate where a poisoning at a high-society ball needs solving. The setting alone makes this stand out from the rest of the pack. Think chandeliers, formal dress, and whispered accusations.

The kit includes 30 plus pieces of physical evidence, including witness statements, police reports, photographs, telegrams, floorplans, newspaper clippings, and forensic notes, plus access to digital evidence online. Playtime is about 4 hours, which is longer than most detective games on this list, but the flexible 1-12 player count means you can spread the work across a large group.

Our team appreciates the affordability here. Compared to premium detective games, Murder at Maple Manor delivers a comparable evidence-based experience at a noticeably lower price point. It is a particularly good choice for book clubs or family game nights where multiple people want to participate.

The honest cons: the review history is shorter (around 125 reviews), so there is less crowd-sourced validation. Some buyers may find the 4-hour playtime too long for a single session, though you can pause and resume. For fans of period drama like Downton Abbey who also love mysteries, this is a uniquely themed pick.

For Whom It’s Good

Ideal for large group game nights, book clubs, and fans of period mysteries. Mystery readers who enjoy gilded-age and Victorian settings will love the theme. Budget-conscious gifters will appreciate the lower price point.

For Whom It’s Bad

Skip if the recipient needs a quick game. Also not ideal for solo players who prefer a tighter, faster mystery experience.

9. Murder Most Puzzling Twenty Mysterious Cases to Solve

Murder Most Puzzling is the most beautiful book on this list. Authored and illustrated by Stephanie von Reiswitz, it offers twenty short mystery cases presented through stylized visuals rather than long text passages. It feels like an art book crossed with a puzzle collection.

Published by Chronicle Books, the hardcover production quality is high. Each case is short enough to read with a cup of coffee, and the variety keeps the experience fresh. Reviewers note that some cases are more challenging than others, which actually adds replay value because you can return to the harder ones later.

This is the kind of book that looks gorgeous on a coffee table and stays there. It also makes an excellent gift for a mystery fan who already owns a mountain of novels and wants something visual and different. Our team agreed it pairs well with a candle and a quiet evening.

The honest cons: with only 96 pages, some mystery readers may finish it faster than they expect. A few reviewers wanted longer cases. For a cozy mystery fan who values aesthetics as much as plot, this remains a charming pick.

For Whom It’s Good

Perfect for visual learners, art lovers, and cozy mystery readers who enjoy short puzzles. Also works as a gift for someone who already owns too many novels and wants something different on the shelf.

For Whom It’s Bad

Skip if the recipient prefers long, text-heavy mysteries or wants deep investigative work. Also not ideal for hardcore puzzle fans looking for hours of content per case.

10. Brain Games Criminal Mind Puzzles Crime-Themed Activity Book

Brain Games: Criminal Mind Puzzles is a 192-page spiral-bound activity book packed with crime-themed brain teasers across visual, verbal, memory, and logic categories. The spiral binding makes it easy to flip pages flat on a desk, which is a small detail that matters during long puzzle sessions.

Our team appreciated the variety. True crime fans will recognize themes throughout the puzzles, and the mix of difficulty levels keeps the book engaging for both casual and experienced puzzlers. It is one of the more affordable gifts on this list, which makes it a great stocking stuffer or add-on.

Reviewers consistently mention that the puzzles range from quick brain warm-ups to genuinely challenging logic problems. That range is what makes the book feel like it lasts longer than its page count suggests.

The honest con: some puzzles skew harder than casual users expect, so a few buyers reported frustration. For a true crime fan who loves puzzles, though, this is an easy recommendation and a smart value pick.

For Whom It’s Good

Best for true crime fans who also enjoy word puzzles, logic games, and brain teasers. Travel-friendly and great for keeping hands busy on a flight or train. Also works as a thoughtful small gift paired with a mug or bookmark.

For Whom It’s Bad

Skip if the recipient prefers narrative-driven mysteries or finds dense puzzle books frustrating. Not ideal for younger kids, since some puzzles assume adult vocabulary.

11. Brain Games Sherlock Holmes Puzzles Volume 1

This is the Sherlock Holmes-specific cousin of the Criminal Mind Puzzles book. Brain Games: Sherlock Holmes Puzzles Volume 1 offers over 100 cerebral challenges inspired by the world’s greatest detective, including cryptograms, word searches, jumbles, and memory games.

The Holmes theme runs throughout, which gives the book a strong identity beyond a generic puzzle collection. Reviewers consistently mention that the vocabulary is challenging and engaging, which is a plus for adults who want more than surface-level puzzles. Our team agreed it is one of the more giftable puzzle books for Sherlock fans specifically.

Like the other Brain Games title, this one is spiral-bound for easy use and runs 192 pages. It is priced affordably, which makes it a strong stocking stuffer or pairing gift alongside a Holmes-themed mug or book.

The honest con: many puzzles assume familiarity with Sherlock Holmes stories or shows, so buyers without that background may find some clues opaque. A few cryptograms are genuinely tough. For a devoted Holmes reader, this is a delightful deep cut.

For Whom It’s Good

A near-perfect fit for Sherlock Holmes fans who also enjoy word puzzles and logic challenges. Great for fans of BBC Sherlock, the original Conan Doyle stories, or both. Affordable enough to pair with another small gift.

For Whom It’s Bad

Skip if the recipient is unfamiliar with Sherlock Holmes lore, since many puzzles lean on canonical knowledge. Also not ideal for very casual puzzlers, since some cryptograms are demanding.

12. The Ultimate Serial Killer Trivia Book

If your gift recipient is the type to debate cold case files at brunch, The Ultimate Serial Killer Trivia Book is a perfect match. Author Jack Rosewood compiles fascinating facts and disturbing details about infamous serial killers across 185 pages, and the trivia format keeps it engaging rather than dry.

Our team found this to be one of the highest-rated books on the list, with a 4.7-star average across 6,000-plus reviews. It makes an excellent small gift and works as a stocking stuffer or a paired present alongside a true crime podcast subscription.

The book is structured for browsing, so it does not need to be read cover to cover. Reviewers say it sparks conversation at parties, and true crime fans appreciate the breadth of cases covered. It is also one of the more affordable picks on this list.

The honest con: the subject matter is inherently dark, which is the appeal for its audience, but it is not appropriate for younger readers or squeamish gift recipients. For a dedicated true crime reader, this hits the mark.

For Whom It’s Good

Best for true crime podcast listeners, fans of shows like Mindhunter or My Favorite Murder, and anyone who treats serial killer trivia as party conversation. Pairs well with a cocktail-themed true crime book for a themed gift bundle.

For Whom It’s Bad

Skip if the recipient prefers cozy or fictional mysteries. Also not appropriate for younger teens or anyone uncomfortable with the dark subject matter.

13. Mixology and Murder True Crime Cocktail Book

Mixology and Murder is one of the most unique gift concepts on this list. Author Kierra Sondereker pairs cocktail recipes with stories of infamous serial killers, cold cases, and cults, all wrapped in a beautifully produced hardcover. It is part bar guide, part true crime anthology, and it works.

The visual design is dramatic, with a high-quality hardcover binding that makes it feel like a coffee table book. Reviewers consistently rate this 5 stars, and our team agreed the format is genuinely fresh. If you know a true crime fan who also loves a good Old Fashioned, this is a no-brainer gift.

The book runs 192 pages and includes back stories for each killer paired with a custom cocktail recipe. It makes a great hostess gift, housewarming present, or paired gift alongside the Sherlock Holmes mug from earlier on this list.

The honest cons: the red text on black glossy paper can be challenging to read in some lighting, which a few reviewers flagged. Some cocktail recipes require specialty supplies, so beginners may need to supplement their bar cart. A small number of buyers reported shipping damage, so consider purchasing through a retailer with strong packaging.

For Whom It’s Good

Best for true crime fans who also enjoy mixology, home bartenders, and anyone who hosts murder mystery dinner parties. A great gift for a host or hostess who loves a themed evening.

For Whom It’s Bad

Skip if the recipient does not drink alcohol or dislikes dark subject matter. Not ideal for casual cooks who want simple recipes.

14. The Serial Killer Cookbook Death Row Last Meals

The Serial Killer Cookbook takes a similarly creative concept to Mixology and Murder, but focuses on death row last meals. Author Ashley Lecker pairs recipes inspired by infamous killers’ final meals with trivia about each case, and the result is a quirky, conversational cookbook that true crime fans actually use.

Our team tested a few of the recipes and found them approachable and not overly complicated, which is exactly what most buyers say. The recipes are not restaurant-quality, but they are fun conversation starters for a themed dinner party. With a 4.7-star average across 1,500-plus reviews, this is a popular pick in the true crime gift category.

It is a paperback with bright photos and a clean layout, and it makes a great gift paired with a bottle of wine or a cocktail kit. Reviewers say it gets people talking at dinner parties, which is exactly the point.

The honest cons: at 128 pages, it is shorter than Mixology and Murder. Some recipes are basic, which disappointed serious cooks. For a true crime fan who enjoys hosting themed dinners, this is a delightful pick.

For Whom It’s Good

Ideal for true crime fans who love hosting, dinner party hosts, and anyone who enjoys a quirky cookbook. Pairs beautifully with Mixology and Murder for a complete true crime kitchen gift bundle.

For Whom It’s Bad

Skip if the recipient is a serious home cook looking for elaborate recipes. Not appropriate for younger audiences or those uncomfortable with the dark subject matter.

15. True Crime Trivia & Activity Book

Rounding out the list is True Crime Trivia and Activity Book by Lana Barnes, a 176-page activity book that combines puzzles and trivia about gripping historical crimes. Published by Zeitgeist in 2024, it offers a more accessible entry point into true crime than the more disturbing picks higher up on this list.

The book mixes trivia, puzzles, and activities rather than focusing purely on one format, which keeps it engaging for casual readers. Our team found it the most approachable true crime book on this list, which makes it a great gift for a curious newcomer to the genre rather than a hardcore fan.

The price point is among the most affordable on this list, which makes it a great stocking stuffer or add-on gift alongside a Sherlock Holmes mug or one of the detective games. Reviewers consistently mention that the activities are fun and varied.

The honest cons: some trivia assumes familiarity with specific cases, so a few buyers found sections tougher than expected. At 176 pages, it is shorter than a few alternatives. For a casual true crime reader who wants an interactive format, this is a thoughtful final pick.

For Whom It’s Good

A great fit for casual true crime fans, younger readers transitioning into the genre, and anyone who enjoys activity books over straight reading. Also works well as a paired gift alongside a true crime podcast subscription.

For Whom It’s Bad

Skip if the recipient already owns the major true crime trivia books or wants something more disturbing and detailed. Not ideal for hardcore true crime devotees who prefer long-form content.

How to Choose the Right Mystery Fan Gift

The biggest mistake shoppers make with mystery fans is defaulting to “another book.” Mystery readers are some of the most prolific readers around, which means they often already own the major titles in their favorite sub-genre. The best gifts avoid that trap by matching the recipient’s preferred flavor of mystery and their reading habits.

Start by identifying the sub-genre. Cozy mystery fans enjoy small-town settings, amateur sleuths, and low-violence puzzles. Classic detective fans gravitate toward Sherlock Holmes, Agatha Christie, Dorothy Sayers, and golden-age locked-room puzzles. True crime fans prefer real cases, podcasts, and documentaries, while thriller readers want psychological tension and high-stakes plots. If you do not know which sub-genre the recipient prefers, opt for a versatile pick like a Sherlock-themed accessory or a short mystery puzzle book.

Next, decide between a physical product, an experience, or a subscription. Physical products like detective games, puzzle books, and themed mugs work for one-time gifts. Experience gifts like live theater tickets, mystery dinner events, or escape rooms create memories. Subscription gifts like audiobook credits, mystery book clubs, or monthly mystery boxes extend the joy over time. Our team found that for the most devoted fans, a combination, like a game plus a Holmes mug, lands better than a single high-ticket item.

Finally, think about reading setup. Does the recipient have a dedicated reading nook? If so, comfort upgrades like reading pillows, blankets, or bookmarks pair well with longer reading sessions. Do they commute? An audiobook-friendly pick or a portable puzzle book is better. Do they love game nights? A cooperative detective game turns mystery enthusiasm into a social activity. For more bookish gift ideas across other genres, our romance reader gift guide and BookTok fan gift guide cover complementary niches.

Budget-wise, this list covers every tier. Under 25 dollars, the trivia books, puzzle books, and the Sherlock Holmes mug all deliver strong value. From 25 to 50 dollars, the detective games from Hunt A Killer and Unsolved Case Files offer the best mix of immersion and replay value. Above 50 dollars, the Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective board game is our top premium pick. If you are shopping for history buffs who love a good period mystery, our Tudor history fan gift guide offers another complementary angle.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Verdict on Mystery Novel Fan Gifts

After six weeks of testing and comparing customer feedback, our top recommendation for the best gifts for mystery novel fans in 2026 remains the Unsolved Case Files: Ashcroft Harmony cold case game. It delivers the strongest combination of immersion, replay structure across three linked mysteries, and crowd-validated quality with over 17,000 reviews and a 4.7-star average. For a true crime devotee, Hunt A Killer: Death At The Dive Bar is our top pick. For a cozy reader or Sherlock fan, the Unemployed Philosophers Guild Sherlock Holmes Coffee Mug is the highest-rated gift on this entire list at 4.9 stars and makes a near-perfect stocking stuffer or paired present.

The best gifts for mystery novel fans are the ones that match how that person actually reads. Match the sub-genre first, then decide between a physical product, an experience, or a subscription. With the 15 picks on this list, you should find something for every kind of mystery reader on your shopping list, from a casual cozy fan to a Sherlock Holmes completist to a true crime binge-watcher. Browse the full roundup above and find the gift that will make the next mystery marathon even better.